![]() I’ve followed the story of the new administration in Washington, DC, and its initial efforts to recast the public narrative across the bureaucratic board, but most interestingly I have been following a small revolution within the National Park Service and staff upheavals in the areas of diplomacy and intelligence at the national level. And after considering all this for a while I found myself buying a bumper sticker through the altNational Parks Facebook page. Here’s why. When I was young my ideas were more untethered. Like a puppy that finds itself suddenly out of the crate and onto the unlimited expanse of the kitchen floor my ideas would head out enthusiastically in random directions, occasionally stumbling into a snout-plant and periodically circling back to a lap or the crate entrance to ensure that in this freedom I was not entirely unmoored. I recall bringing myself to a point in my enthusiasm as a young person where a quote (attributed, correctly, to me) in a local free publication caught the eye of my employer, whose arm metaphorically thrust up through the floor from the offices below and yanked me downstairs to remind me that perhaps I didn’t know the complete story, and at the very least my narrative did not conform to that of the organization. I was off-message – in a somewhat large and troubling way. I survived that reminder to continue to speak freely, if more discreetly, to my leadership, but I find that my ideas still stray out of the yard now and again. I’ve also understand now more clearly that there are many fine reasons why it is a good practice to allow them to sometimes lie quietly in the sun inside the fence before I start looking for a hole in it. The collective intelligence of a large organization is complex. It is not simple to know enough to speak for the whole while being unaware of the ideas of the parts, and any organization depends not only on good leadership to set the direction and speak this intelligence, but also on the freedom of those at the far reaches of the organization to communicate honestly to leadership. This is best done and most effectively done, I have found, internally – person-to-person, a “crucial conversation” as often termed in the organizational development world, respecting the broadening responsibilities of everyone up the chain to the top, and the challenges that come with existing on those lofty levels. These systems work well when a few simple things are true. There must be respect from above to below, about the work one performs and the knowledge one must have to effectively accomplish even the smallest and most mundane tasks. If this is not true there will be little respect afforded from below to those above. There must be no secrets within the chain of communication. If mysteries exist the novelist in us all fills the vacuum with the story that’s most fun and likely most outrageous. There must be care that people with differing opinions are not marginalized or muzzled, but listened to. Even if the organization does not absorb their narrative, it must be seriously considered and debated at the very least. The AltNPS movement sprung up in late January when the administration issued an order through the Department of the Interior to stop scientists from speaking of or publishing any material on climate science (one of the key resource management issues in the National Park system today) and shut down all social media outlets in the Parks for a wide variety of content. A number of employees, starting with a small group from Badlands National Park on the vanguard of the Twitter storm (some others in the Twitterverse started calling it Badass National Park), decided to resist and spend their off-duty hours outside the crate on the kitchen floor, off-message, defending the work of the Park Service to perform their mission using the best science, arguing that there was no consensus built about this silencing of park staff, and no respect for the scientists closest to the issue within the organization, and being generally critical of the new administration. This list has since expanded to people purportedly representing staff in Arches, Shenandoah, Yosemite, Yellowstone, Grand Canyon, the Blue Ridge Parkway, Everglades, and Great Smoky Mountains National Parks. Well, I found my own ideas about this scurrying about the floor. Yes, clearly it is the right and perhaps even the responsibility for senior leadership in a large organization to set the public agenda, develop a leadership message and expect the ideas of those within the organization to stay in the crate so as not to confuse those outside the organization. And mostly that has held true at the crux of transitioning administrations throughout our national history. It works (except in this case) because the organizations follow the unwritten rules of internal dynamics – the seniors respect the knowledge and ideas of those at the far reaches of the organization, messaging is distanced from managing and dissent is channeled internally where it is tended and massaged before a decision is made. There are no mysteries – the reason a new narrative exists is clear and clearly passed down the line. The only thing that is clear in this case is that the message passed down from the new administration is not. Some things are off limits (“national policy” issues like climate change, which to me seems like a scientific issue), and others are not (safety, information, etc.). Little consultation seems to have taken place down the line to staff in the parks before the social media orders were handed down. The scientists whose work has been to try to get ahead of threats to the parks in the future found their work censored without any internal discussion. What is going to happen to this effort to manage the parks in a way “as will leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations” (1916 Organic Act creating the National Park Service) if the very experts we hire to figure out how to do this are not listened to? It’s a mystery and you know what people do when faced with a mystery… Although my inclination is to let my ideas bask a little in the sun within the fence for a while, I find myself rooting just a little for the AltNPS puppies out there on the kitchen floor. It’s not a model that is sustainable in any organization, but I’m interested to see how this little bit of chaos might change the outcome. In time my hopes are that the level of respect up and down returns and the suddenness of activity at the top of the organization moderates a little so there is less need for rangers to speak on social media on their own time and for diplomats to publicly challenge their new superiors before they are even on the job. We have thousands of outstanding rangers across the political spectrum dedicating their lives to the parks, monuments and historic sites, as well as a knowledgeable and experienced team of international experts in the foreign service. Any wise leader understands that you don’t encourage the dogs to stay in the fence by shooting at them or tying them to a tree. Make sure they feel they are still part of the pack. Respect them and listen before acting and there’ll be a lot less howling.
15 Comments
1/20/2019 09:54:46 am
Do you also get offended when some men can't even look at you straight in the eye when speaking? How weak can they be? Are you really that beautiful that they can't help but get distracted? I don't think so. I can't believe there are still religious groups who give men the wrong notion that women are inferior and that you cannot take their decisions and attitude seriously. If they are mad, it's always never because men are wrong. For them it's only because they are women and they don't care.
Reply
3/30/2019 08:53:44 pm
My son is starting to learn how to socialize and in as much as I want to keep him to myself all the time, I realised maybe it's time to slowly learn to let go. They say you should focus more on your relationship with your husband and wife because at the end of the day, all of your children are going to get married and have kids of their own and they will leave you eventually. You will be left alone if you will not find the love of your life who is going to stay with you until your hair turns fray. I think it's too early to feel this way but I am already feeling so alone now. I feel if my son is busy with his friends, nobody is going to take care of me now.
Reply
6/5/2024 03:44:13 am
The piano, with its 88 keys, is a versatile instrument capable of producing a wide range of tones. It’s central to classical, jazz, and popular music, providing both harmony and melody. Learning the piano involves understanding scales, chords, and finger techniques, making it a foundational instrument for many musicians.
Reply
6/5/2024 04:11:52 am
Car shipping brokers act as intermediaries between customers and carriers. They can provide multiple quotes and help navigate the complexities of the shipping process. While brokers offer convenience and potential cost savings, it's important to research their reputation and ensure they work with reliable carriers.
Reply
6/5/2024 04:16:53 am
For a touch of luxury, Penticton offers high-end wine tours featuring premium tastings and gourmet meals. These exclusive tours often include transportation in luxury vehicles, private cellar access, and the finest wine selections. The combination of elegance and indulgence ensures a sophisticated and memorable experience.
Reply
6/5/2024 04:20:57 am
The restoration process often involves addressing foundation issues. Log home restoration specialists are skilled in repairing and stabilizing foundations, ensuring the structural integrity of the home from the ground up.
Reply
6/5/2024 04:56:50 am
Vacation rentals in Bend often feature extensive outdoor spaces, perfect for enjoying the region's sunny weather. Large decks, patios, and gardens provide ideal spots for barbecues, gatherings, or simply unwinding with a good book. These areas allow you to fully embrace the outdoor lifestyle Bend is known for.
Reply
6/5/2024 04:59:55 am
Nutrition plays a crucial role in achieving envious lashes. A balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals, particularly biotin, vitamin E, and omega-3 fatty acids, can promote healthy lash growth. Supplements can also be beneficial if you’re not getting enough nutrients from your diet.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:04:09 am
The consequences of using a fake degree certificate can be severe, including legal ramifications and damage to one's reputation.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:08:58 am
Homeowners in Denver often use their garages for more than just parking cars. They serve as workshops, storage areas, and even recreational spaces. A well-insulated and secure garage door can enhance the usability of this versatile space, making it more comfortable and secure for various activities.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:13:48 am
Contractors may provide warranties or guarantees on their workmanship to offer peace of mind to property owners.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:18:00 am
One of the primary benefits of online separation agreements is the ease of access. Couples can create these agreements from the comfort of their homes, saving time and reducing stress. Additionally, online platforms often provide templates and guidance, ensuring that all necessary legal considerations are addressed comprehensively.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:23:21 am
Many Lemoore storage units are equipped with pest control systems to prevent infestations that could damage stored items. This proactive approach helps maintain the integrity of belongings, especially for long-term storage situations.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:28:18 am
Homeowners should also keep vegetation trimmed away from the garage door to prevent moisture buildup and pest infestations.
Reply
6/5/2024 05:38:55 am
Valparaiso's climate makes window tinting a practical choice for many residents. During hot summers, tinted windows reduce the heat entering homes and vehicles, improving comfort levels. In winter, they provide an insulating effect, helping to retain heat inside and lower heating costs, demonstrating year-round benefits.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorDaniel Howe lives in Raleigh, NC. He's interested in a lot of things so this blog is all over the place. Archives
May 2018
Categories |